Institute for Business Ethics

www.unisg.ch
Choose INSTITUTE
  • Institutes
  • ACA-HSGInstitute of Accounting, Control
    and Auditing
  • CFM-HSGCenter for Mobility
  • FAA-HSGForschungsinstitut für Arbeit
    und Arbeitswelten
  • FGN-HSGInstitute of Economics
  • FIM-HSGResearch Institute for
    International Management
  • FIR-HSGResearch Center for
    Information Law
  • FWR-HSGForschungsstelle für Wirtschaftsgeographie
    und Raumordnungspolitik
  • GIMLA-HSGSt.Gallen Institute of
    Management in Latin America
  • IBB-HSGInstitute for Educational
    Management and Technologies
  • IMP-HSGInstitute for Systemic Management
    and Public Governance
  • IORCF-HSGInstitut for Operations Research
    and Computational Finance
  • IPW-HSGInstitute of Political Science
  • IRM-HSGInstitute of Retail Management
  • ISCM-HSGInstitute of Supply Chain Management
  • IWE-HSGInstitute for Business Ethics
  • IWP-HSGInstitute of Business Education
    and Educational Management
  • MCM-HSGInstitute for Media
    and Communications Management
  • MED-HSGSchool of Medicine
  • OPSY-HSGResearch Institute for Organizational Psychology
  • SBF-HSGSwiss Institute
    of Banking and Finance
  • SEW-HSGSwiss Institute for
    Empirical Economic Research
  • SFS-HSGResearch Institute of Sociology
  • SGI-HSGSGI-HSG St.Gallen Institute of Management in Asia
  • SIAW-HSGSwiss Institute for International Economics
    and Applied Economic Research
  • WBZWeiterbildungszentrum Holzweid
  • Center
  • ACC-HSGAsia Connect Center
  • CDI-HSGCompetence Center for Social Innovation
  • CDI-HSGCenter for Disability and Integration
  • CFAC-HSGCenter for Aviation Competence
  • CFB-HSGCenter for Family Business
  • CFI-HSGCenter for Innovation
  • CFM-HSGCenter for Mobility
  • CHC-HSGCenter for Health Care
  • CLS-HSGCentro Latinoamericano-Suizo
    de la Universidad de San Gallen
  • FR-HSG
  • GCE-HSGCenter for Governance and
    Culture in Europe
  • GCEI-HSGGlobal Center for
    Entrepreneurship & Innovation
  • GP-HSGGender Portal
  • HDZ-HSGHochschuldidaktisches Zentrum
  • Smart Government LabSmart Government Lab
  • TME-HSGTransformative Management Education
Logo University of St.Gallen
  • About us
    • A Brief History
    • Team
    • IWE transparent
    • Social Media
    • Press
  • Initiatives
    • Competence Center for African Research
      • About the Competence Center for African Research
      • Reports CCAR and Ethics Lab
      • Upcoming Events
      • Associates and Projects
      • Collaborations
    • Responsible Commodity Trading
      • The Swiss Commodity Sector as a Matter-of-Public-Concern
      • Hard and Soft Commodities
    • Young Researchers Summit
      • About YRS
      • Organizers
      • Upcoming Events
      • Call for Abstracts
      • Past Events
      • Good Business
      • YRS Network
  • Research
    • Research projects
      • The Human Right to Health and Health Care
      • Symbolic Forms of Remedy for Corporate Human Rights Impacts
      • Blurred Team Boundaries: Multiple Team Membership in Open-Source Software Development Teams
      • Early Institutional Entrepreneurship in Hostile Contexts
      • Smart Cities and Human Rights
    • Publications
      • Latest Publications
      • All Publications
  • Teaching
    • Current Courses
    • Ktx: Area of Concentration Responsibility
    • BA/MA Topics
  • Search
  • Language
    Deutsch
    English
  • Login
  • EN-Social Media, Newsletter
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
  • EN-Universität spezifische Links
    • Sitemap
    • Contact
Mobile Navigation

You are here:

  1. IWE
  2. Initiatives
  3. Competence Center for African Research
  4. Reports CCAR and Ethics Lab
  5. Brocher Symposium
Current navigation level
Previous navigation level
Next navigation level
Current navigation level
  • About the Competence Center for African Research
  • Reports CCAR and Ethics Lab
  • Upcoming Events
  • Associates and Projects
  • Collaborations
Next navigation level
Current navigation level
  • Brocher Symposium
  • Webinar on The Concept of Minority, a Critical Appraisal
  • Webinar on Digital Transformation
  • Book Workshop
  • Ethics Lab Conference 2020
  • CCAR Launch Event St. Gallen, 2020
  • Ethics Lab Launch Week
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Print this page
Share on LinkedIn Share on Google+ Share on Pinterest E-mail

Brocher Symposium 2021

Covid-19 and the Human Right to Health: What is really at stake for Africa?

Co-Organized by the Competence Center for African Research, University of St. Gallen, Switzerland and the Ethics and Public Policy Laboratory of the Catholic University of Central Africa, Cameroon

 Topic description

Gray areas remain on our scientific knowledge of COVID-19 which continues to afflict a significant portion of the world’s population. The acute impact is clear. Risks of infection and deaths are highest in the more disadvantaged and vulnerable sectors of the population in higher income countries. In lower income settings, infection and death rates are not clear. It is possible that death rates are lower, given potential existence of cross-reacting protective antibodies or the overall younger average age of the general population. The economic effects are being felt world-wide, again with the greatest impact in countries without a social safety net. The medium and long-term implications of the pandemic will however most likely be disproportionately felt in lower resource settings, especially in terms of health and the fall out of job losses, loss of education and the disruption of many other health programmes (such as immunizations, tuberculosis, non-communicable disease care etc).

With several months of hindsight now, that the anticipated health catastrophe in Africa has not yet materialized, although some prominent figures have died from COVID-19, and countries such as South Africa, Kenya and Ethiopia are dealing with a high number of infections. Corruption in the hardest hit countries such as South Africa and Kenya is exposing the ruthlessness of decision makers and their indifference to the health of the general population. Similar corruption may be occurring elsewhere but in more robust societies the impact may be less evident. The current outbreak is therefore still very concerning for Africa, albeit not for the same reasons as in higher income settings. The African CDC rallied early on, lockdowns were instituted early, and therefore Africa may even be considered to have acted more responsibly and in a timelier fashion than other countries. However, the fragility of the economies, health systems and governance structures leave individuals extremely vulnerable. African countries have also not been able to compete on the global market for fair pricing of personal protective equipment, medication and will likely be at the end of the line when it comes to accessing any vaccines.

When this virus began to spread around the world, there was a ‘paternalistic’ claim, which mostly reflects a broader Western perspective unfortunately relayed by some in Africa, that African countries may not recover from this pandemic, as it would impose something like a double penalty to already very broken African health care systems and weak economies. Based on that ‘paternalistic’ analysis, the ‘paternalistic’ solution was also quickly suggested: rich countries should quickly do something to help the very poor African countries who would never be able to manage a pandemic of such magnitude by their own; and many African States did not fail to ask for help right away.

However, by focusing on what we observe rather than on what we believe we know about the African context, we could have foreseen scenarios closer to reality that explained why the situation is less acutely shattering than expected, and should focus on the real health challenges posed by this pandemic for Africa, of which 2 stand out:

The first challenge is the fact that this pandemic is diverting attention from more prevalent and lethal conditions than COVID-19, such as malaria, HIV-AIDS, TB, maternal health and non-communicable diseases, which, combined, lead to many million deaths a year. It is not a question of competition between diseases, but simply of remaining aware of the local health challenges such that responses are adapted adequately in terms of public health policies. African countries should be responsible not to exacerbate spread of the virus within and beyond their borders, but this cannot be the only priority (imposed by the global community) when more or equally pressing other health problems also need urgent attention, to prevent loss of prior gains (e.g, Malaria, HIV, TB) or worsening of already suboptimal baseline outcomes (e.g. NCDs).

The second challenge is how much local African governments should take the human right to health of their own citizens seriously and develop sound and coherent national health care policies that make that human right effective. This pandemic, which has forced many countries to close their borders, has forced us to face the obvious reality, sometimes forgotten, that the fate of the health of each citizen depends first and foremost on their state, and that the national framework remains the place par excellence to make human rights like the right to health effective. The human right to health of each African should also be considered relative to the human right to health of all citizens of all countries. Global stewardship and solidarity is also necessary to permit governments to protect the human right to health of their citizens.

Being aware of the real challenges posed by this pandemic for Africa would prevent African states and governments from making as usual the copy-pasting of outward health strategies and would force them for once to develop sound public health policies that are adapted to African demography and contexts, serve the local needs and really protect the human right to health of African people.

This symposium expects to address these challenges and others as they relate to the protection of health as a human right in Africa.

 

Participants:

Elisio Macamo | Sociologist, University of Basel, Switzerland

Neema Kaseje | Clinician, global health expert, University of Geneva, Switzerland

James Tataw | Physician, Geneva University Hospital, Switzerland

Samia Hurst | Physician, Geneva University Hospital, Switzerland

Caesar Atuire | Philosopher, University of Ghana-Legon, Ghana (Zoom)

Victor Ng'ani | Medical Director, RFH Specialist Hospital, Kenya (Zoom)

Joy Mugambi | Family Physician, Secretary General WONCA Africa Region, Kenya (Zoom)

Thierry Ngosso | Philosopher, University of St.Gallen, Switzerland

Abdoulaye Guindo | Anthropologist, University of Bamako, Mali (Zoom)

Wase Musongue Ediague | Lawyer, World Trade Organization, Switzerland (Zoom)

Alain Kenfack Foguena | Physician, Hopital du Jura bernois, Switzerland (Zoom)

Charles Kwanin | Global health policies expert, University of Geneva

Yorbana Seign-Goura | Sociologist, University of Neuchatel, Switzerland

Dawit Ayana | Materials & chemical engineer, Addis Ababa University (Institute of Technology), Ethiopia

Kebene Wodajo | Law and economics, University of St. Gallen, Switzerland

Victorine Chibueze | University of Geneva, Switzerland 

contact

Thierry Ngosso

Email

downloads
  • Brocher Symposium

Accreditations

EQUISAACSBAMBA

Member of

Logo CEMSLogo PIMLogo APSIALogo gbsn

© Copyright 2022 University
of St.Gallen Switzerland · General
legal information · Privacy Policy

Dufourstrasse 50
CH-9000 St.Gallen
Tel +41 71 224 21 11
Fax +41 71 224 28 16

University of St.Gallen - School
of Management, Economics, Law,
Social Sciences, International Affairs
and Computer Science

From insight to impact

Navigation
  • Search
  • Language
    Deutsch
    English
  • Login
  • EN-Social Media, Newsletter
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
  • EN-Universität spezifische Links
    • Sitemap
    • Contact
  • About us
  • Initiatives
  • Research
  • Teaching
  • A Brief History
  • Team
  • IWE transparent
  • Social Media
  • Press
  • Competence Center for African Research
  • Responsible Commodity Trading
  • Young Researchers Summit
  • About the Competence Center for African Research
  • Reports CCAR and Ethics Lab
  • Upcoming Events
  • Associates and Projects
  • Collaborations
  • Brocher Symposium
  • Webinar on The Concept of Minority, a Critical Appraisal
  • Webinar on Digital Transformation
  • Book Workshop
  • Ethics Lab Conference 2020
  • CCAR Launch Event St. Gallen, 2020
  • Ethics Lab Launch Week
  • Gallery CCAR Launch Event
  • Workshop with Afronomicslaw
  • 7th Yaoundé Seminar 2022
  • Enforceable Brand Agreements
  • Humanizing Pedagogy
  • Thierry Ngosso
  • Rose Wangui Kimotho
  • Kebene Kejela Wodajo
  • Marta Domínguez Díaz
  • Florian Elliker
  • Tina Freyburg
  • Charles Gottlieb
  • Roland Hodler
  • Sebastian Kernbach
  • Ehtics Lab
  • The Ethics Institute
  • The Swiss Commodity Sector as a Matter-of-Public-Concern
  • Hard and Soft Commodities
  • About YRS
  • Organizers
  • Upcoming Events
  • Call for Abstracts
  • Past Events
  • Good Business
  • YRS Network
  • BHR Young Researchers Summit 2022
  • BHR Young Researchers Summit 2021
  • BHR Young Researchers Summit 2020
  • BHR Young Researchers Summit 2019
  • BHR Young Researchers Summit 2017
  • BHR Young Researchers Summit 2016
  • Participants
  • Research projects
  • Publications
  • The Human Right to Health and Health Care
  • Symbolic Forms of Remedy for Corporate Human Rights Impacts
  • Blurred Team Boundaries: Multiple Team Membership in Open-Source Software Development Teams
  • Early Institutional Entrepreneurship in Hostile Contexts
  • Smart Cities and Human Rights
  • Latest Publications
  • All Publications
  • Current Courses
  • Ktx: Area of Concentration Responsibility
  • BA/MA Topics